Monday, May 9, 2011

Hamlet's Dilemma

In my opinion, I don't agree with the hesitation of Hamlet when it came to killing Claudius.  Even if Claudius has done any harm to Hamlet or his loved ones, it still doesn't give him the right to take his life.  He shouldn't hesistate to take Hamlet's life because he could put himself  in a dangerous situation.  If Claudius is guilty for whatever he's done, he will suffer the consequences in the long run.  You know what they say, what goes around comes right back around.

Sunday, May 8, 2011

To Be or Not to Be

I didn't like Oliver's version of to be or not to be.  The setting wasn't very interesting because it was by a river near a cliff and it was in black and white.  Some movies that doesn't contain color doesn't really draw attention towards me.  This version doesn't have an effect because it was boring.  The director is trying to convey that Hamlet was thinking about suicide because as he's lying down by the cliff, he's holding a dagger in his hand.  Yes, there was music and it makes the mood kind of dark and suicidal.
 I actually like Branaugh's version . The setting took place in a castle in front of a mirror.  This version was kind of awkward because he was looking in the mirror and talking to himself.  There was music, but it was very soft and soothing.  In this scene Hamlet was played very clear and dramatically, so this version really drew my attention.  Personally, I think this version was the best out of all of them.
 Zeffirelli's version wasn't as good as Branaugh's version, but it was still played very well by Mel Gibson.  The setting was in the catabombs under the castle and the effects was gloomy.  Even though there wasn't any music, Mel Gibson still did an outstanding job on directing ad playing his role as Hamlet.  I like how the setting was in a dark dungeon with tombstones of dead people.  To be honest, i think this version had the best setting.